When someone changes for the better, we often celebrate what they’ve left behind.
The shy child becomes a confident adult. The cautious employee becomes a decisive leader. Someone who once avoided difficult conversations learns to speak with courage.
But what happens to the qualities that served them before they changed?
Must becoming stronger mean abandoning the person we used to be?
The Torah raises this question through a curious detail in the story of Jacob.
After twenty years away, Jacob is returning home. He has built a family, acquired wealth, and survived the schemes of his dishonest uncle Laban. Yet his brother Esau, who once threatened to kill him, is approaching with four hundred men.
Jacob prepares carefully. He sends gifts, divides his household into camps, and prays for protection.
Then, during the night, a mysterious figure wrestles with him until dawn.
Jacob is injured, but refuses to release his opponent without receiving a blessing.
The stranger declares:
“Your name shall no longer be called Jacob, but Israel, for you have struggled with G-d and with men, and have prevailed” (Genesis 32:29).
Jacob has earned a new name.
But here is the surprise.
The Torah continues calling him Jacob.
When G-d changed Abram’s name to Abraham, the old name disappeared. Scripture consistently called him Abraham thereafter.
Yet after Jacob becomes Israel, the Torah uses both names.
Why?
The Lubavitcher Rebbe explains that Jacob and Israel represent two different ways of serving G-d, and both remain necessary.
The name Jacob is connected to the Hebrew word for “heel.” It recalls the man who survived through caution, persistence, and resourcefulness, sometimes finding indirect ways to accomplish what seemed impossible.
Israel represents a higher level. It is the name of someone who has struggled and prevailed, who can face challenges with a different kind of confidence.
But the new name does not erase the old one.
There are times when life requires the strength of Israel: the courage to confront wrongdoing, defend a principle, or face a difficult truth.
And there are times when we need Jacob’s quieter strengths: patience, discretion, perseverance, and the wisdom to recognize that not every conflict should become a confrontation.
The Rebbe’s teaching reveals something easily overlooked about spiritual growth. Becoming stronger does not mean that every quality we possessed before was a weakness.
Jacob’s caution helped him survive twenty years with Laban. His resourcefulness protected his family. His perseverance enabled him to build a future.
Those qualities were not mistakes to be discarded.
They were part of the man who became Israel.
The same is true in our lives. Someone who learns to speak up need not lose the ability to listen. Someone who develops confidence need not surrender humility.
Maturity is not replacing one personality with another. It is learning which strengths a particular moment requires.
And that brings us back to Jacob’s remarkable night.
He emerges from the struggle with a new name, but also with a limp. His victory has left a mark.
The Torah does not give us a flawless hero who has outgrown every limitation. It gives us a man who has discovered a new dimension of himself without ceasing to be the person he was.
Last week’s portion described Jacob’s dream of a ladder reaching from earth to heaven. The sages taught that the angels saw an exalted image of Jacob above, far greater than the sleeping traveler below.
Now, after twenty years in the world, Jacob begins to fulfill that vision.
He has not become someone else.
He has become more fully himself.
That is why the Torah keeps both names.
We are not asked to erase our past in order to grow beyond it. We are asked to bring our earlier strengths into the service of something greater.
Jacob became Israel.
And he remained Jacob.
I wish you a good week and Shabbat Shalom,
Rabbi Yonatan Hambourger
This post has been contributed by a third party. The opinions, facts and any media content are presented solely by the author, and Atlanta Jewish Connector assumes no responsibility for them. Want to add your voice to the conversation? Publish your own post here.













































